Sherrill New York Pizzeria in Sherrill

Frigin poop since Frank left absolute garbage will never ever order again

Great pizza and everything wings!

Good pizza and has slices

I love the food there. I'm a real big fan of their pizza rolls, and Pizza. People that work there are great too. The only real complaint I have is their prices are a little high, and they charge you a dollar for a small cup of sauce which you should get when you buy pizza rolls anyways.

This is the only local pizza place we order from. I've always loved the New York Pizzeria chain but the Sherrill location is one of the best. The only con I have is my pizza is usually not cooked as long as I like; I prefer my entire pie to have a nice golden semi-crispy finish.

In my opinion Sherrill New York Pizza has the best pizza in the area. Treir sausage rolls are also good.

Great pizza

Best med hot wings I've ever had friendly people great service. If you haven't been there your missing out

Good tasting pizza, great prices, although they need to keep the pizza racks replenished!

Good food and a great staff.

amazing food and amazing customer service. never disappointed.

Really good everything chicken wings, however worst pizza ever!

I absolutely love not only their Pizza but their wings, there garlic knots are pretty good and their ham rolls, pizza rolls and meatball rolls I'm not only very good but reasonably priced, my only knock on the place is that I wish they put more meat in the rolls, for an example their ham roll only has one slice of ham in it..the ham roll is my favorite!I just don't see two slices of ham Breaking the Bank lol

Laid back environment. Employees are very "bro." Tight knit group. Old building. Small dining room. But more than adequate for taking an hour away from work schedule to enjoy a slice. Always plenty of variety in terms of slices. Their buff chicken is by far their best slice, it's a must try!

Luv the Hot Hame an Provolone Subs and There Pizzza is Amazing

Great pizza and wings. Only complaint I have is when I order wings the come with too much sauce. Literally the wings are submerged in sauce. Way to much.

Great pizza and staff thank you!!!

Awesome food and service

Great hawaiian pizza. The garlic wings were cooked perfectly. And they delivered right to our campsite

They are great people. Always polite and respectful.

Best pizza in the state!

Great pizza. Efficient staff.

Had some issues with our pick up order tonight that Sherrill NY Pizzeria went out of their way to make up for!! Things happen... more often that not, life throws the curve ball and the ability to roll with it gracefully (in my opinion) is what makes for success! Everything was absolutely delicious and we couldn't be happier! Our #1 pizzeria!!

Some of the best pizza I have ever had.

New improvements all around Pizza was the best I have had in a long time. Staff is great....as I'm writing this all I want is another pizza lol

It's a pizza shop. New york-style thin niced I could have been in the oven a little longer to warm it up otherwise no complaints.

Great pizza and wings NY style

Great place, staff is cool, pizza is great, what's not to like, thumbs up all around

The past couple times has left a bad taste, was just given grief for asking for my room temperature slices to be heated. Still trying to figure out why I went out of my way to go here. This place used to be so good...

No better place on the planet to get pizza!! Anyone from around the area knows this

Impressive place. Ive never had a calzone so loaded before, and the fried dough has amazing! This was a random stop on the way through the state on my way to NH with my family. I Wish i live here just to eat here again!

Great pizza! Haven't tried anything else yet but I plan to.

Got a sicilian buffalo chicken. Amazing. Great pizza

I think the people are nice, but I think the sauce you use is very bland and makes pizza taste gross, also I have found hair in my french fries. I think everyone should be waring a hairnet if working around food.

Best place around for pizza.

Amazing calzones and great prices

Awesome pizza, will be back.

This place has good food! You ought to give it a try. Guaranteed, you'll be back!!!

The guys behind the bar are nice and the pizza flavorful! I’d go again.

The pizza was very good, and the counter staff courteous. The pizza came out in lightning speed! The cheese was still white and not toasted, but very good nonetheless. The sauce had nice flavor too. I couldn't give 5 stars because the bathrooms needed attention, however the dining room was pretty neat. I would definitely return.

We are visiting from out of town and wanted some pizza. This place nailed it. The pizza was awesome, the staff was friendly, and slices were inexpensive highly recommend

Great place even better great food!!

Great pizza at a great price.

pizza slices are kinda big and very good peperoni roll is amazing

I have been eating from this location ever since Frank opened it up back in the 80's. The owners after his departure have done a great job in keeping up the quality and taste of the food made here and even making or adding improvements over the years. Great small town pizza shop!

Super good!

Great food and staff, they are always friendly and respectful.

Workers was very helpful and nice food was good

Delicous food and fast delivery.

Great pizza compared to the surrounding 20 miles